Antique "picker" Jane Wheel is making a career out of going through old things; it seems she can't get enough of the piles of vintage clothing, kitchen utensils, old newspapers and report cards she finds at estate sales across the Chicago area.

As she's cataloging her loot one Saturday afternoon, however, Jane makes a gruesome discovery. Packed between the glassware, bowling trophies, and old photographs, she uncovers a human finger entombed in a tiny jar.